Are MIN shares or REA shares better value in 2025?

The Mineral Resources Ltd (ASX:MIN) share price has fallen 49.7% since the start of 2024. It's probably worth asking, 'is the MIN share price in the money?'

You’re reading a free article on Rask. Join 4,000+ Australians who get our expert advice, tools, exclusive research and investment recommendations. Get your 30-day trial for $1! Learn more

The Mineral Resources Ltd (ASX:MIN) share price has fallen 49.7% since the start of 2024. Meanwhile, the Rea Group Ltd (ASX:REA) share price is 5.8% away from its 52-week high. This article explains why it could be worth popping MIN and REA shares on your watchlist.

MIN share price in focus

Mineral Resources Limited (MIN) is a diversified Australian mining company primarily focused on the extraction of lithium and iron ore in Western Australia.

In addition to its mining operations, MIN offers mining and engineering services to external clients through its wholly-owned subsidiary, CSI Mining Services (CSI). CSI provides capital infrastructure and operational expertise across Western Australia, Queensland, and the Northern Territory.

What sets Mineral Resources apart from its competitors is its in-house engineering and construction capabilities, which provide full control and flexibility throughout the product development process.

REA shares

Founded in 1995, REA Group is a Melbourne-based real estate advertising company, with News Corp as its majority shareholder. It is best known in Australia for its flagship platform, Realestate.com.au.

REA Group operates globally, managing property websites across 10 countries, serving around 20,000 property agents. In Australia, its core website attracts over 55 million visits per month, and the Australian operations still contribute the majority of the company’s revenue. REA generates income primarily by charging property owners for listings, facilitated through agents who use the platform to showcase properties for sale or rent. The company also earns revenue through financial services, such as mortgage broking, though this remains a smaller portion of the business.

REA’s competitive edge lies in its strong network effects and economies of scale. With significantly more users and views than its closest competitor, Domain, REA is well-positioned to dictate pricing and market dynamics. Additionally, REA benefits from its diversified presence across the real estate ecosystem, including property listings, advertising, mortgage broking, and house-sharing services.

MIN & REA share price valuation

We would consider MIN to be a ‘mature’ or ‘blue-chip’ business, so some of the metrics that could be worth considering include the debt/equity ratio, average yield, and return on equity, or ROE. These measures give us a sense of the company’s debt levels, their ability to generate returns from their assets, and their ability to consistently return profits to shareholders.

For FY24, Mineral Resources Ltd reported a debt/equity ratio of 148.9%, meaning the company is leveraged (it has more debt than equity). This can increase risk so it’s important that a leveraged company is generating stable returns and has sufficient cash flow to pay interest on its debts.

Over the last 5 years, MIN has delivered an average dividend yield of 2.4% per year. This is important to note if you’re looking for income from your investments.

Finally, in FY24, MIN reported an ROE of 3.2%. For a mature business you generally want to see an ROE of more than 10%, so MIN’s returns are a bit less than what we’d expect.

As a growth company, some of the trends we might consider from REA shares include revenue growth, profit growth, and return on equity (ROE). I say ‘trends’ because it’s always important to look at these figures over a few years. The trend is much more valuable info than a single measure at one point in time.

Over the last 3 years, REA has increased revenue at a rate of 18.6% per year to hit $1,677m in FY24. Meanwhile, net profit has fallen from $323m to $303m. REA’s last reported ROE was 18.9%.

Please keep in mind that context is important. These metrics give us some indication of company performance, but it’s just the start of valuing MIN or REA shares. To learn more about valuation, check out one of our free online investing courses.

CSL, Xero, ANZ... the ASX is beaten up

Right now, only brave investors are buying. Is ASX Reporting Season your KEY opportunity to act? Buy, or sell.

This coming Monday night, our two most experienced professional investors, Owen Rask and Leigh Gant, are hosting an exclusive and rare webinar on the what to watch this ASX reporting season. LIVE and free

With over 35 years of combined investing experience, join our Chief Investment Officer and Head of Content for our free Q&A.

We’ll be diving into results from CSL, Pro Medicus (ASX: PME), ANZ Bank and more. It’s absolutely free to join us. Take advantage of this volatility with our free playbook. Simply click here to view the topics.

A $50,000 per year passive income special report

Join more 50,000 Australian investors who read our weekly investing newsletter and we’ll send you our passive income investing report right now.

How can Rask help you?

About Rask

Learn more about us, our your community and our mission.

Rask investing philosophy

Nearly 15 years later.
It's still a work in progress.

Online investment community

You won't find our investment community on Facebook or Reddit because it's secure, free and available now.

Join 250,000+ podcast listeners

250,000 investors tune into the Rask podcasts every month. Find out why.

Find a financial planner

Australia's financial experts. At your doorstep.

Free finance courses

35,000 students have enrolled in free Rask courses. We're on a mission to 100,000.

Subscribe to Rask's free investor newsletter

53,000 Australian investors subscribe to our Sunday newsletter... and love it! It's free.

$50 million invested

We manage almost $50 million on behalf of Aussies. Discover how you can invest with us.

Better investing starts here.

Want to level-up your analytical skills and investing insights but don’t know where to start? Join 50,000 Australian investors on our mailing list and we’ll send you our favourite podcasts, courses, resources and investment articles every Sunday morning. Grab a coffee and let Owen and the team bring you the best  insights.

5%+ in passive income

Get Rask’s special investing report

With bond ETFs like ASX:IAF and the S&P 500 riding high, now could be one of the best times to start earning passive income from a portfolio of shares and ETFs.

In this free analyst report, our Chief Investment Officer, Owen Rask, names 10 ASX stocks and ETFs to watch.

Unsubscribe anytime. Read our TermsFinancial Services GuidePrivacy Policy. We’ll never sell your email address. Our company is Australian owned.

Subscribe to Rask's free investor newsletter

Kick off your week with our pick of podcasts, courses and investing resources to keep your finger on the Rask pulse!

Here you go: A $50,000 per year passive income special report

Join more 50,000 Australian investors who read our weekly investing newsletter and we’ll send you our passive income investing report right now.

Simply enter your email address and we’ll send it to you. No tricks. Unsubscribe anytime.

Unsubscribe anytime. Read our TermsFinancial Services GuidePrivacy Policy. We’ll never sell your email address. Our company is Australian owned.