Search ASX code:
Generic filters

Search ASX code:
Generic filters

Search ASX code:
Generic filters

Search ASX code:
Generic filters

Are Share Purchase Plans (SPPs) For ASX LICs Worth It?

“We are pleased to announce a SPP that offers you a chance to buy shares at a 5% discount to the recent market price, without incurring any brokerage.”

That’s a typical comment from the management of an ASX Listed Investment Company or LIC when they are looking to raise capital (click here to learn what a capital raising is and what SPPs are). Although the company may be pleased with more money, as shareholders should we also be pleased?

A nice discount and no brokerage may sound good, but it all depends. Let’s start off with a positive frame of mind and examine a situation where it is a win/win.

A Prudent Share Purchase Plan (SPP)

Some LICs on the market are as little as $50 million in size. Whether the LIC is small or large there are fixed costs within the structure that don’t differ all that much. The amounts needed for various administration expenses, directors’ fees, accountancy fees, etc., won’t change too much regardless of the money in the fund (AUM). In order to reduce the burden of such costs it makes sense for a small LIC to try and grow its investable assets.

Note that I am assuming the extra AUM won’t hurt the chances that the LIC/fund outperforms in the future. If the LIC is trying to pick microcap stocks on the ASX then trying to grow to billions of AUM will obviously make outperforming difficult.

Another benefit is if the LIC sees quite attractive buying opportunities where it can deploy the fresh capital (assuming they have deployed it well in the past!). This could remove the need to sell existing positions where it may be difficult to do so. It can also avoid unnecessary selling that crystallises tax payable.

A very important point for the LIC in considering an SPP is if the shares are trading at a discount or premium to NTA. The latter may enable them to issue new shares above the current NTA. This is accretive to the NTA and may result in upward pressure on the share price.

A More Likely Situation?

We can’t ignore the point though that new capital raised from a SPP also can boost the amounts the fund manager may pay themselves.

The manager will usually receive a fixed percentage of AUMs as a fee, therefore there is an added incentive to grow the funds. I refer here to the model of externally managed LICs which make up the vast majority of the sector.

With the internally managed LICs such as Australian Foundation Investment Company (ASX: AFI) and Argo Investments (ASX: ARG) it is different. Any perceived conflict of interest issues are therefore likely to be less apparent with some of the internally managed LICs.

A sign that the manager might be motivated by the increase in AUM and fees is if they conduct a SPP at a large discount to NTA. The dilution to NTA that occurs from this will not please loyal shareholders or management. The difference though is that management may stand to benefit from fees earned on the additional capital over the decades ahead. Therefore, management in this case have a much greater tolerance for any dilution compared to shareholders.

Questions To Ask

As a shareholder, the discounted SPP offer to recent market prices looks attractive on the surface. Yet to qualify for the SPP you would already have an existing holding. Does the announcement of the SPP put downward pressure on your existing investment? Does a short term discount on a SPP offer make up for any dilution to the NTA of your overall shareholding?

A trap that a LIC investor can fall into is taking up an offer to buy more shares regularly and unintendedly boosting his or her weighting to an underperforming LIC. If the SPP is at a significant discount to market prices I suggest not to rush into applying for shares. It is worth exploring the possibility of at least selling some of your existing holding first, so you don’t fall into this trap.

Justifications For SPPs Or Excuses?

There will always be justifications from management for raising more capital from investors.  It is easy for any LIC to cite a reduced fixed costs burden and there being attractive opportunities out there in the market. Another typical argument is the liquidity of the shares will improve and the LIC will get more of a profile within the sector. It is all subjective though and I would keep a sceptical mindset over such claims.

If management are running the portfolio well then it should be quite easy for the LIC to have the funds available to buy new opportunities anyway. The same applies to making the LIC more relevant in the marketplace in terms of coverage. Well managed LICs will get noticed. There are so many disappointing ones to make them stand out!

What Should Shareholders Consider?

The problem lies when the value of the NTA is diluted in trying to achieve outcomes. If the LIC already has hundreds of millions under management, the costs / benefits need to be weighed up carefully. Will extra shares offer significant improvements to shareholders? Is it worth the resultant significant dilution in the NTA if the shares need to be offered at a sizeable discount?

These aspects must be considered on a case by case basis. The important thing is to not be blinded by only thinking about the current SPP offer versus the current share price. There are usually bigger issues at play to weigh up.

If you’re looking for our #1 ETF of 2019 get our free report below…

Disclosure: At the time of publishing, Steve Green does not own shares in Australian Foundation Investment Co. Ltd. or Argo Investments Limited.

Are you stuck wondering where to invest right now? Have you got cash 'sitting on the sidelines'? Are you looking for dividend income AND growth but don't know where to start? Rask's expert ASX analyst team has just released a full report, detailing where we'd invest $10,000 right now.

Not only are we offering these 11 investment ideas completely FREE, we've also released an in-depth podcast to go with the report!

So, whether you have $2,000 or $50,000, our brand new analyst report could help transform your watchlist. Right now, you can get the full analyst report emailed to you for FREE by CLICKING HERE NOW or simply entering your email below.

Unsubscribe anytime. Read our TermsFinancial Services GuidePrivacy Policy. We’ll never sell your email address. Our company is Australian owned.

Are you stuck wondering where to invest right now? Have you got cash 'sitting on the sidelines'? Are you looking for dividend income AND growth but don't know where to start? Rask's expert ASX analyst team has just released a full report, detailing where we'd invest $10,000 right now.

Not only are we offering these 11 investment ideas completely FREE, we've also released an in-depth podcast to go with the report!

So, whether you have $2,000 or $50,000, our brand new analyst report could help transform your watchlist. Right now, you can get the full analyst report emailed to you for FREE by CLICKING HERE NOW.

Information warning: The information on this website is published by The Rask Group Pty Ltd (ABN: 36 622 810 995) is limited to factual information or (at most) general financial advice only. That means, the information and advice does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. It is not specific to you, your needs, goals or objectives. Because of that, you should consider if the advice is appropriate to you and your needs, before acting on the information. If you don’t know what your needs are, you should consult a trusted and licensed financial adviser who can provide you with personal financial product advice. In addition, you should obtain and read the product disclosure statement (PDS) before making a decision to acquire a financial product. Please read our Terms and Conditions and Financial Services Guide before using this website. The Rask Group Pty Ltd is a Corporate Authorised Representative (#1280930) of AFSL #383169.

LIVE ASX Chat - Join in!

Keep reading:

ASX

A $2.3 million retirement challenge

In the lead up to (and in) retirement, I think too many people make costly mistakes with their money. So, I asked two financial planners how they’d tackle this problem.

Read More

Rask Analyst’s $10,000 Hypothetical Portfolio 

Rask Australia’s expert analysts have just released 11 stock & ETF positions they’d buy right now as part of a $10,000 hypothetical portfolio. 

Completely free, this report comes with the exact ticker codes, how much the analysts would invest and a detailed over the company and why we like it. Plus a 60-min podcast! 

Simply enter your email address and we’ll send you the report.

Unsubscribe anytime. Read our TermsFinancial Services GuidePrivacy Policy. We’ll never sell your email address. Our company is Australian owned.