Afterpay Touch Group Ltd (ASX: APT) shares are amongst the fastest-growing on the entire Australian Stock Exchange (ASX). The company’s growth has been rewarded by the market, with its share price increasing a staggering 297% in the last year.
Afterpay received a boost in late February when the Senate Standing Committee on Economics did not recommend expanding the National Credit Code to encompass buy-now-pay-later providers.
Afterpay’s success has not gone unnoticed with other ‘buy now pay later’ providers looking to cash in by listing on the Australian Stock Exchange (ASX). Here’s what you need to know.
How do Afterpay’s ASX listed rivals stack up?
Afterpay is the most popular ‘Buy Now, Pay Later” provider in Australia with over 2.5 million active customers. Afterpay also has in excess of 700 thousand active customers in the U.S and growing quickly.
Afterpay allows customers to receive the product right away and then make interest free repayments every fortnight over 4 equal installments. To buy now pay later with Afterpay, you must have a MasterCard or Visa debit/credit card.
Although no interest is charged, a maximum late fee of $10 will be charged if a payment is missed (for purchases under $40). However, Afterpay generates the majority of its revenue by charging fees to its Merchants/retailers. According to its recent half-year annual report, Afterpay currently earns fees of around 3.7% on merchant sales.
For the first half of the 2019 financial year, Afterpay reported revenue of $107.1 million, up 124% on the prior comparable period. However, Afterpay reported a loss after tax of $22 million, increasing from $700,000 in the prior comparable period.
Zip Co Limited (ASX: Z1P) provides consumers with interest free loans of loans of up to $1,000 at more than 12,000 retailers in Australia under its ‘Zip Pay’ product. Zip advertises to its merchants that they ‘wear all the risk, both credit and fraud, so once the transaction is approved you’re guaranteed payment’.
Although no ‘interest’ is payable the customer is charged $6 every month if they have a balance outstanding. Zip also offers loans of over $1,000 with a 3-month interest-free term. Aside from account fees, Zip primarily generates revenue from its merchants. This fee is approximately 2-4% of the transaction value made through its platform.
Revenue lifted an enormous 114% to $34.2 million in the half year to 31 December 2018. Notwithstanding the huge growth in revenue, Zip reported a net loss of $6.7 million for the period.
Clearly the sharemarket has been impressed with Zip’s results to date, with the share price ‘zipping’ an incredible 185% higher over the last year.
Splitit Payments Ltd. (ASX: SPT) listed on the ASX in January this year and its share price is up a phenomenal 459%. Splitit allows customers to split their repayment into as many as 36 interest-free monthly payments. Customers must have an existing Visa or Mastercard to utilise Splitit’s platform.
Splitit generates 100% of its revenue from fees charged to merchants based upon sales made via its Splitit Payment Platform. Unlike all of its competitors mentioned in this article, it does not charge its customers any late fees. Further, Splitit has structured its product so that credit risk is shifted to the merchant or an external financier.
Splitit released its annual results in late March, with revenue of just $789 thousand (USD). At the the time of reporting, Splitit had 380 active merchants, up from 175 on the year before. Although Splitit recorded strong top-line growth, it incurred a net loss of $4.6 million (USD) up from $3.4 million (USD) in the prior financial year.
Flexigroup Limited (ASX: FXL) has not fared well over the last year with its share price down about 30%. Revenue for the half to 31 December 2018 increased 7% to $236.1 million and ‘underlying’ cash NPAT (Net Profit after Tax) excluding non-recurring items of $41.9 million down 3% on the prior year.
Flexigroup currently earns about 25% of its income from its buy now pay later products, recently simplified and rebranded to Humm. I’m not too sure about the name!
To utilise Humm customers must have an Australian credit card or debit card (VISA or MasterCard). Although Flexigroup offers a buy now pay later product, it generates the bulk of its income (45%) from credit cards.
Humm allows customers to make interest free repayments for purchases up to $30,000. For purchases under $2,000, the customer can choose to repay over 5 or 10 fortnights. For purchases between $2,000 and $30,000, repayments must be made over a period of up to 60 months.
An initial late fee of $6 will be charged to the customer if a payment is missed, whereas a $30 collection fee could be charged if Flexigroup takes steps to recover an unpaid balance.
Sezzle is a US-based buy now pay later provider which, according to the AFR, has plans to list on the ASX. Sezzle’s website advises that it allows customers ‘to purchase today, and make 4 interest-free payments over 6 weeks’.
Sezzle is currently offered only to US-based customers and assumes all credit and fraud risk of purchases made via its platform. Sezzle has partnered with over 3,500 merchants to date and has stated this number is growing quickly.
On the surface, Sezzle’s product is most similar to that offered by Afterpay. It will certainly be one to watch closely when it announces its date to list on the ASX and releases its prospectus.
Are These ASX Shares A ‘Buy Now’?
Although Afterpay, Splitit and Zip have printed high levels of revenue growth, none has earned a profit in their most recent reported results. Therefore I would not consider purchasing shares in these companies at this time. However, if or when either reports a profit, their share prices could be considerably higher.
Despite Flexigroup reporting a profit, I find their business strategy to grow its credit card products and ‘buy now pay later’ divisions concurrently a bit puzzling. Mainly because buy now pay later products are utilised as an alternative to credit cards.
Further, taking on the credit risk of providing customers interest-free loans of up to $30,000 seems risky. I would like to see how Humm is performing after at least a year of introduction.
Shares in Sezzle cannot be purchased yet, however, I will be closely watching their progress towards listing on the ASX.
ACCESS OUR NEW SMALL CAPS INVESTING REPORT!
After searching through a market with over 2,000 shares, our lead expert investment analyst has narrowed it down to just 2 of his favourite small-cap pocket rocket share ideas in a FREE report to Rask Media readers.
Over the past five years, these two shares have gone from being 'tiny caps' to being serious contenders for the ASX 300.
Access the free report by clicking here now or enter your email below! Absolutely no credit card or payment details required.
Disclaimer: Any information contained in this article is limited to general financial/investment advice only. The information has not taken into account your specific needs, goals or objectives, so please consider consulting a licenced and trusted adviser before acting on the information. Please read The Rask Group’s Financial Services Guide (FSG) for more information. This article is authorised by Owen Raszkiewicz of The Rask Group, which is a corporate authorised representative No. 1264179 of Strawman Pty Ltd (ACN: 610 908 211) (AFSL: 501 223).
At the time of publishing, William does not have a financial interest in any of the companies mentioned.